I have finally picked new bedding. There's no turning back and no returning this time. Thanks to everyone who gave me suggestions! I really appreciated it. I ended up going with Serena and Lily's "Graham" Bedding. It was something Jackson and I both loved (a difficult accomplishment). I will post pictures of the nursery when we get things all set up. I've got a shower this coming Saturday and then the Saturday after that! I'm so excited :)
Here's a picture of the bedding.